Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Worst person in the world

Yesterday, the Hall of Fame Veterans Committee announced… nothing. After much deliberation, posturing, campaigning and whatever else the baseball folks with their secret ballots do, the Veterans Committee decided to tell good folks like Ron Santo, Marvin Miller, Buck O’Neil, Gil Hodges, Walter O’Malley and Jim Kaat to, well… maybe we shouldn’t rephrase it.

Let’s just say it ends with “… and die.”

Some already have.

Let's start with the fact that the Baseball Hall of Fame is watered down. Based on some invisible criteria that elected borderline players – statistically speaking – it’s a real crime that Santo, O’Neil, Hodges, O’Malley, Don Newcombe and gasp! Marvin Miller can’t get the votes.

Do those electors have a clue as to what their mission is?

So what’s the deal with these folks? Is there anything that can be done about possibly taking the Hall of Fame voting away from the Veterans Committee and some sycophants in the Baseball Writers Association of America?

No. Probably not.

Nevertheless, it doesn’t mean we can’t pick on them. At least that’s what Keith Olbermann did last night on his show Countdown. In his nightly feature, “Worst Person in the World,” Olbermann awarded the top place to the Veterans Committee (ahead of Anne Coulter and some guy who e-mailed a bomb threat into his school) saying they should do the correct thing and quit.

Here’s Olbermann:

But our winners tonight: The Baseball Hall of Fame Committee on Veterans. Given a choice of such overlooked immortals as Gil Hodges and Ron Santo, Jim Kaat and Maury Wills, and such movers-and-shakers as Dodger owner Walter O'Malley, and players' union founder Marvin Miller.

Today, they elected... nobody.

Santo came closest – five votes short of the spot in the Hall of Fame he has long deserved. There will not be another vote until 2009... 2011 for the non-players.

The electors – including 61 current Hall of Famers – should voluntarily resign their positions, or be compelled to. They have made fools of themselves.

Again.

The Baseball Hall of Fame Committee on Veterans, Tuesday's Worst Persons In The World!


Here’s an idea for the Hall of Fame – let’s start over. Let’s take everyone out of the Hall of Fame… Babe Ruth, Walter Johnson, Cy Young, etc., etc. and vote them back in. You know, rebuild it all from scratch. This time contributions to the game, citizenship and playing ability all count.

And let’s get people to vote on them who really care. Olbermann should get a vote. Bob Costas, too. Just not the same old, same old people who have been doing it in the past. The world changes, elements of baseball should as well.

On another note...
Barry Bonds needs bigger shoes.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Cleaning house

Only 10-year members of the Baseball Writers Association of America are eligible to vote for the Hall of Fame. To be a member of the BBWAA, one has to work for a daily newspaper or The Associated Press, which, in the changing landscape of the media seems almost as archaic and anachronistic as allowing one specific group vote for something that some folks find so virtuous.

No, I’m not a member of the BBWAA. Plus, I agree with Woody Allen’s sentiment that I would never join an organization that would have someone like me as a member.

But that doesn’t mean I don’t have an opinion on the most recent voting by the BBWAA to enshrine just Cal Ripken and Tony Gwynn is the equally as anachronistic Hall of Fame. I guess this is because I don’t seem to understand what it takes to be a Hall of Famer any more.

Let’s start with this – if I had a vote for the Hall of Fame balloting, I would have voted for Cal Ripken, Tony Gwynn and Jim Rice. Ripken and Gwynn are obvious choices and epitomize – in my view – what the Hall of Fame is supposed to be about. Rice gets my vote because in 1978 he was the best player in the game, and from 1978 to 1986 he always one of the most feared hitters in either league.

Baseball statistics really don’t mean much to me and serve no other purpose than to back up specific arguments. That said, the following players would have received careful consideration from me (if I had a vote):

· Bert Blyleven
· Andre Dawson
· Rich Gossage
· Tommy John
· Jack Morris
· Dale Murphy
· Dave Parker
· Lee Smith

I keep changing my mind on Blyleven, and depending upon who is on the ballot next year, I suspect I’d give big Bert and that nasty curveball the vote. Andre Dawson and Dale Murphy fall into similar circumstances as Rice since there was a stretch in the 1980s where both players – specifically Murphy – were the best hitters in the league.

I’m not so sold on Goose Gossage because I mostly remember him as an oft-injured reliever who bounced from team to team in the latter part of his career. Tony Perez did that, too, and I don’t think he should be in the Hall of Fame either.

Why not Perez? Well, that’s easy. He was never the best player on any of his teams, let alone the best player in the league. Then again, if Perez is in than everyone on the list posted above ought to be in, too.

Actually, if Perez is in then why isn’t Chili Davis or Andres Galarraga? How about Dwight Evans or Harold Baines? What about Joe Carter or Rusty Staub?

Maybe it’s time to start taking people out of the Hall of Fame? Maybe it’s time for the Hall of Fame to take the vote away from the BBWAA and give it to a more inclusive organization – or at least one that will be around in the next decade.

Actually, that sounds like a fun exercise… who should we take out of the Hall of Fame? Let’s start with Perez and follow it up with:

  • Bill Mazeroski
  • Jim Bunning
  • Phil Rizzuto
  • Red Schoendienst
  • Enos Slaughter
  • Rick Ferrell
  • George Kell
  • Travis Jackson
  • Hack Wilson
  • Addie Joss
  • Joe Sewell
  • Roger Connor
  • Freddie Lindstrom
  • George Kelly
  • Lefty Gomez
  • Ross Youngs
  • Dave Bancroft
  • Jake Beckley
  • Chick Hafey
  • Harry Hooper
  • Joe Kelley
  • Rube Marquard
  • Earle Combs
  • Jesse Haines
  • Lloyd Waner
  • Red Faber
  • Elmer Flick
  • Eppa Rixey
  • Edd Roush
  • Max Carey
  • Ted Lyons
  • Ray Schalk
  • Dazzy Vance
  • Rabbit Maranville
  • Bobby Wallace
  • Buck Ewing
  • Jim O’Rourke
  • Johnny Evers
  • Joe Tinker
  • Frank Chance
  • Tommy McCarthy
  • Roger Bresnahan
  • Herb Pennock

    Granted, I know about as much about Ray Schalk as I do about nuclear physics, but judging from the fact that most of the players on the list are inductees from the Veterans Committee it seems as if they got in because they were “good guys” or were liked by the right people. So if that’s a criterion, let Dale Murphy in and keep Perez in there, too.

    Then again maybe Ray Schalk was as good as Sandy Koufax or even Jim Rice for a few seasons?

    While we’re at it, answer this question: How many voters out there liked Mark McGwire in 1998? It seems to me that he filled a lot of writers’ notebooks and even made some a little bit of money, too.

    Is Mark McGwire’s bid at baseball immortality being sacrificed for Major League Baseball’s sins? Or was he a willing partner in the dance of death?

    Labels:

  • Tuesday, November 28, 2006

    Why the Hall not?

    The ballots for the 2007 Baseball Hall of Fame class are out and without getting too much into it, there is a little hubbub about certain candidates. Nevertheless, if I had a vote –- which I don’t –- here are the players I would select for enshrinement:

  • Tony Gwynn
  • Jim Rice
  • Cal Ripken Jr.

    The following is a list of candidates that I liked, but wouldn’t select for one reason or another:

  • Bert Blyleven
  • Andre Dawson
  • Rich Gossage
  • Tommy John
  • Jack Morris
  • Dale Murphy
  • Dave Parker
  • Lee Smith

    Am I missing anyone?

    A couple of notes: This could be the first Hall of Fame ballot where I was old enough to see every one of the candidates play. In fact, I remember Dave Parker’s famous throw in the 1979 All-Star Game and Jim Rice’s epic 1978 season. I remember Andre Dawson in 1987, Dale Murphy in 1982 and ’83 and Jack Morris pitching in the greatest World Series game ever.

    Additionally, maybe they could come up with a new rule where a one person is removed from the Hall of Fame after every five are elected? Let’s start with Tony Perez and Bill Mazeroski.

    Labels:



  • © 2006 - John R. Finger - all rights reserved